"What Do Workplace Wellness Programs Do? Evidence from the Illinois Workplace Wellness Study" (with Damon Jones and David Molitor) (under review)
Workplace wellness programs cover over 50 million workers and are intended to reduce medical
spending, increase productivity, and improve well-being. Yet, limited evidence exists to support
these claims. We designed and implemented a comprehensive workplace wellness program for a
large employer with over 12,000 employees, and randomly assigned program eligibility and
financial incentives at the individual level. Over 56 percent of eligible (treatment group)
employees participated in the program. We find strong patterns of selection: during the year prior
to the intervention, program participants had lower medical expenditures and healthier behaviors
than non-participants. However, we do not find significant causal effects of treatment on total
medical expenditures, health behaviors, employee productivity, or self-reported health status in
the first year. Our 95% confidence intervals rule out 78 percent of previous estimates on medical
spending and absenteeism. Our selection results suggest these programs may act as a screening
mechanism: even in the absence of any direct savings, differential recruitment or retention of
lower-cost participants could result in net savings for employers.
"The Mortality and Medical Costs of Air Pollution: Evidence from Changes in Wind Direction" (with Tatyana Deryugina, Garth Heutel, Nolan Miller, and David Molitor) (under review)
We estimate the causal effects of acute fine particulate matter (PM 2.5) exposure on mortality and health care use among the US elderly using Medicare administrative data and a novel instrument for air pollution: changes in the local wind direction.
We then develop a new methodology that uses machine learning to estimate the number of life-years lost due to PM 2.5.
We find that, while unhealthy individuals are disproportionately vulnerable to air pollution, the largest aggregate burden is borne by those with medium life expectancy, who are both vulnerable and comprise a large share of the elderly population.
"Mortality Risk, Insurance, and the Value of Life" (with Daniel Bauer and Darius Lakdawalla)
We develop a novel economic framework for valuing improvements in health and apply it to data in order to explore the relationships between annuity programs, the value of life-extension, and the value of preventing illness. Incorporating incomplete annuitization and stochastic mortality into the conventional economic theory of life-extension generates several new findings. First, public annuity programs boost the demand for life-extension. For instance, US Social Security adds $11.5 trillion (10.6 percent) to the current value of post-1940 longevity gains. Second, in contrast to the conventional theory, a given mortality improvement may be worth more, not less, to patients facing shorter lives. Holding income and wealth constant, the value of statistical life (VSL) can soar by over $1 million following a health shock that lowers life expectancy. Thus, existing economic analysis may be undervaluing treatment of severe illnesses relative to mild ones. This result also reconciles an empirical puzzle with the economic approach to valuing life, because consumers often report a preference for extending life among people with the bleakest survival prospects. Finally, we introduce a new concept, the value of statistical illness (VSI), which quantifies the willingness-to-pay to avoid falling ill and includes VSL as a special case. Our framework implies that treatments are worth more than prevention, all else equal. Using real-world data, we calculate that treating illnesses such as cancer and heart disease is worth two to five times more than saving an equivalent number of life-years by preventing these conditions.
"A Model of Addiction and Social Interactions" (revisions requested, Economic Inquiry)
Many consumer behaviors are both addictive and social.
Understanding how these two phenomena interact informs basic models of human behavior, and matters for policymakers when the behavior is regulated.
I develop a new model of demand that incorporates both addiction and social interactions and show that,
under certain conditions, social interactions reinforce the effects of addiction.
I also show how the dynamics introduced by addiction can solve the pernicious problem of identifying the causal effects of social interactions.
I then use the model to illustrate a new and important identification problem for studies of social interactions: existing estimates cannot be used to draw welfare conclusions or even to deduce whether social interactions increase aggregate demand.
Finally, I develop a method which allows researchers to distinguish between two common forms of social interactions and draw welfare conclusions.
"The Long-Run Dynamics of Electricity Demand: Evidence from Municipal Aggregation" (with Tatyana Deryugina and Alex MacKay) (under review)
Economic theory suggests that demand is more elastic in the long run relative to the short run, but evidence on the empirical relevance of this phenomenon is scarce. We study the dynamics of residential electricity demand by exploiting price variation arising from a natural experiment: the introduction of an Illinois policy that enabled communities to select electricity suppliers on behalf of their residents. Using a flexible difference-in-differences matching approach, we estimate a one-year price elasticity of -0.16 and three-year elasticity of -0.27. We also present evidence that consumers increased usage ahead of these announced price changes. Finally, we project that the price elasticity converges to a value between -0.30 and -0.35 after ten years. Our findings highlight the importance of accounting for consumption dynamics when evaluating energy policy.
"Did Medicare Part D Reduce Mortality?" (with Jason Huh). Journal of Health Economics, May 2017, 53: 17-37.
[Data and code]
We investigate the implementation of Medicare Part D
and estimate that this prescription drug benefit program reduced elderly mortality by 2.2 percent annually.
This was driven primarily by a reduction in cardiovascular mortality, the leading cause of death for the elderly.
There was no effect on deaths due to cancer, a condition whose drug treatments are covered under Medicare Part B.
We validate these results by demonstrating that the changes in drug utilization following the implementation of Medicare Part D
match the mortality patterns we observe.
We calculate that the value of the mortality reduction is equal to $5 billion per year.
"The Insurance Value of Medical Innovation" (with Darius Lakdawalla and Anup Malani). Journal of Public Economics, January 2017, 145: 94-102.
[Data and code]
Economists think of medical innovation as a valuable but risky good, producing health benefits but increasing financial risk for consumers and healthcare payers. This perspective overlooks how innovation can lower physical risks borne by healthy patients facing the prospect of future disease. We present an alternative framework that accounts for all these sources of value and links them to the value of healthcare insurance. We show that any innovation worth buying reduces overall risk and generates positive insurance value on its own. We conduct a stylized numerical exercise to assess the potential empirical significance of our insights. Our calculations suggest that conventional methods meaningfully understate the value of historical health gains and disproportionately undervalue treatments for the most severe illnesses, where physical risk to consumers is the costliest. These calculations also suggest that the value of physical insurance from new technologies may exceed the financial spending risk that they pose.
"Interpreting Pre-trends as Anticipation: Impact on Estimated Treatment Effects from Tort Reform" (with Anup Malani). Journal of Public Economics, April 2015, 124: 1-17.
[Data and code]
While conducting empirical work, researchers sometimes observe
changes in outcomes before adoption of a new policy. The conventional
diagnosis is that treatment is endogenous. This observation is also
consistent, however, with anticipation effects that arise naturally out of
many theoretical models. This paper illustrates that distinguishing
endogeneity from anticipation matters greatly when estimating treatment
effects. It provides a framework for comparing different methods for
estimating anticipation effects and proposes a new set of instrumental
variables to address the problem that subjects' expectations are unobservable.
Finally, this paper examines a specific set of tort reforms that was not
targeted at physicians but was likely anticipated by them. Interpreting
pre-trends as evidence of anticipation increases the estimated effect of these
reforms by a factor of two compared to a model that ignores anticipation.
"Incentives for Reporting Disease Outbreaks" (with Ramanan Laxminarayan and Anup Malani). PLOS ONE, March 2014, 9(3): e90290.
[Data and code]
Countries face conflicting incentives to report infectious disease outbreaks. Reports of outbreaks can prompt
other countries to impose trade and travel restrictions, which has the potential to discourage reporting. However, reports
can also bring medical assistance to contain the outbreak, including access to vaccines. We compiled data on reports of meningococcal meningitis from 54
African countries between 1966 and 2002, a period marked by two events: first, a large outbreak reported from many
countries in 1987 associated with the Hajj that resulted in more stringent requirements for meningitis vaccination among
pilgrims; and second, another large outbreak in Sub-Saharan Africa in 1996 that led to a new international mechanism to
supply vaccines to countries reporting a meningitis outbreak.
We find that the Hajj vaccination requirements started in 1988 were associated with reduced reporting, especially
among countries with relatively fewer cases reported between 1966 and 1979. After the vaccine provision mechanism was
in place in 1996, reporting among countries that had previously not reported meningitis outbreaks increased. These results indicate that countries may respond to changing incentives to report outbreaks when they can
do so. In the long term, these incentives are likely to be more important than surveillance assistance in prompt reporting of
"The Relation Between Variance and Information Rent in Auctions" (with Brett Katzman and Jesse Schwartz).
International Journal of Industrial Organization, March 2010, 28(2): 127-130.
This paper examines the conventional wisdom, expressed in McAfee and McMillan's (1987) widely cited survey paper on auctions, that links increased variance of bidder values to increased information rent. We find that although the conventional wisdom does indeed hold in their (1986) model of a linear contract auction, this relationship is an artifact of that particular model and cannot be generalized. Using Samuelson's (1987) model, which is similar but allows for unobservable costs, we show that increased variance does not always imply increased information rent. Finally, we give the appropriate measure of dispersion (different from variance) that provides the link between the bidder value distribution and information rent.
Works in Progress
"The Wind's Fatal Blow: the Effect of Transported Air Pollution on Mortality" (with Tatyana Deryugina, Nicole Reimer, and Matthew West)
"Driver Licensing Laws and Mortality: Evidence from a Regression Discontinuity Design" (with Jason Huh)
"Does Medicare Improve Quality of Life?"
"Evasion or Stockpiling? The Effect of Anticipated Future Tax Changes on Gasoline Sales" (with Don Fullerton)
Investigator, "The Impact of Temperature and Pollution on Mortality, Morbidity, and Health Care
Cost Among the Elderly" (with Tatyana Deryugina, Garth Heutel, Nolan Miller, and David Molitor), National Institute on Aging, R01 AG053350, 07/2016-06/2021, $1.6 million.
Principal Investigator, "The Illinois Workplace Wellness Study" (with Damon Jones, David Molitor, and Laura Payne), $2.1 million.
Upjohn Institute Early Career Research Award, "Worksite Wellness: A Field Experiment on Participation Incentives and Selection into Wellness Programs" (with David Molitor), 2017, $5,000.
|National Institute on Aging,
|J-PAL North America,
|National Science Foundation,
|Robert Wood Johnson Foundation,
Other selected publications
"Healthy, Body Weight, and Obesity" (with Darius Lakdawalla).
Oxford Handbook of Economics and Human Biology, (Oxford University Press), 2016.
The rise in obesity has generated enormous concern among policy makers and the general
public. Economists have focused on explaining the causes of this rise, along with the
attendant implications for public policy. This chapter summarizes the economic literature
on the theory of weight determination, including the optimal determination of food intake
and exercise, and the influence of prices and peer effects. In addition, the chapter reviews
the empirical literature that tests a range of explanations for the rise in obesity, such as
declining food prices, increasing price of exercise, rising income, peer effects, and the decline in cigarette consumption.
"The Complex Relationship Between Healthcare Reform and Innovation" (with Darius Lakdawalla and Anup Malani).
The Future of Healthcare Reform in the United States, (University of Chicago Press), 2015.
In this chapter we examine some of the interesting and important ways in which healthcare
reform, particularly expansion of health insurance, affects innovation.
We argue that the complexity and uncertainty of the relationship between
insurance and innovation puts a premium on ability to experiment with alternative forms of healthcare reform.
"Tools to Address Illinois Revenue: Increasing Sin Taxes."
State Tax Notes, June 2014, 707-711.
In this report, I estimate the revenue that could be generated by increasing
Illinois sin taxes on cigarettes, alcohol, and gambling. I discuss the efficiency
and distributional effects of those taxes, as well as potential savings from
a reduction in cigarette and alcohol consumption.
© Copyright Julian Reif. All rights reserved
Steve's free web templates